How to make safe and tasty homemade mayonnaise without taking unnecessary risks

Wednesday 4 June 2025 09:06 - Patricia González
How to make safe and tasty homemade mayonnaise without taking unnecessary risks

We explain how to prepare and preserve your homemade mayonnaise to avoid health problems without giving up the authentic flavor of this classic sauce.

There is nothing like a well-made homemade mayonnaise. Creamy, with just the right amount of acidity, capable of transforming a Russian salad, a calamari sandwich or some deviled eggs into something much more special. But just as important as mastering its texture is knowing how to prepare it safely. Because, although it may seem harmless, this sauce can become a risk if it is not prepared and preserved correctly, especially when the heat arrives.


The risk of raw eggs

The traditional recipe starts with a raw egg yolk or a whole egg that is beaten with oil and a touch of acid such as vinegar or lemon juice. The magic of the emulsion occurs thanks to the lecithin in the yolk, which binds ingredients that do not normally mix. But with that magic also comes risk. If the egg is not in good condition, the mayonnaise can become a breeding ground for salmonella.

That's why the choice of egg is key. It is essential that they are very fresh, with the shell intact and without visible traces of dirt. Although it may seem otherwise, it is not advisable to wash them just before use. Water can allow possible bacteria on the surface to penetrate inside, especially if there are invisible cracks or micro-cracks.

Yolk or whole egg?

On a technical level, egg yolk is more efficient at emulsifying. It contains a higher concentration of lecithin, which favors a stable and homogeneous mixture. In addition, the result is usually denser and more unctuous. It is also possible to use whole eggs if a lighter and more fluid texture is required, always respecting the appropriate hygienic and preservation conditions.

The role of acid in the recipe

Although vinegar or lemon juice may seem like secondary ingredients, their role is essential for food safety. The acid lowers the pH of the mixture and creates a less favorable environment for bacterial growth. In fact, it is this acidity that makes mayonnaise a safer preparation than many believe, as long as it is kept well refrigerated and consumed quickly.

How long does homemade mayonnaise really last in the refrigerator?

Unlike industrial mayonnaise, which incorporates preservatives, homemade mayonnaise has a very limited shelf life. It is safest to prepare it just before serving and keep it cold if you are going to wait a few minutes. According to the Egg Institute, it should not be kept for more than eight hours in the refrigerator. Other sources such as the OCU (Organization of Consumers and Users) extend this margin to 24 hours. In any case, if it has not been consumed during the day, it should be discarded. Reusing leftovers from the previous day may seem like a good idea, but it entails an unnecessary risk, especially in summer.


* We know that in Argentina the use of raw or hard-boiled eggs in sauces such as mayonnaise generates some mistrust for health reasons. In such cases, the safest option is to opt for pasteurized eggs, as required by professional gastronomy regulations, or to resort to egg-free versions of mayonnaise.

What happens in bars and restaurants

In catering establishments, the regulations are clear. Mayonnaise may not be made with raw egg. The law requires the use of pasteurized eggs in liquid or powdered form to guarantee the safety of the product. This precaution, mandatory in catering, can also be applied at home, especially if cooking for small children, the elderly, pregnant women or people with compromised immune systems.

Details that also matter (and a lot)

Beyond the ingredients, it is important to pay attention to the utensils. It is important that they are clean and have not been in contact with meat, fish or other raw foods. Cross-contamination is one of the main enemies of food safety in domestic cooking and, in preparations like this, there is no margin for carelessness.

Enjoyment without risk

Preparing homemade mayonnaise is a simple and gratifying gesture, but it should be done responsibly. With fresh eggs, a touch of acid, good hygiene and time control, you can enjoy this sauce without worries. Because home cooking can also be safe without sacrificing its most authentic flavor.

3 recipes to make your own homemade mayonnaise

Homemade mayonnaise with olive oil

Preparation time: 6 minutes
Ingredients (serves 4): 1 egg, 1 tablespoon lemon juice, 3.5 fl oz/100 ml extra virgin olive oil, salt to taste.
Utensils: Blender
Step by step: Place the egg, lemon juice and salt in a blender jar. Beat for a few seconds until the ingredients are well integrated. Add the olive oil in a trickle, little by little and without stopping beating. Keep a constant rhythm so that the emulsion forms correctly. Stop when the mayonnaise has the desired texture. Serve or refrigerate immediately.


Homemade Mustard Mayonnaise

Preparation time: 10 minutes
Ingredients (serves 4): 1 egg, 1 teaspoon vinegar (regular or Modena), 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard, salt, 9 fl oz/250 ml sunflower oil.
Utensils
Mixer
Step by step: Place the egg in a blender cup and add the vinegar, mustard and a pinch of salt. Mix quickly with a fork until the preparation is homogeneous and let stand about 20 seconds for the mustard to act on the egg. Beat with the mixer resting on the bottom of the glass without moving it and gradually add the oil in a thin trickle until the mayonnaise emulsifies and acquires the desired consistency. Keep refrigerated or use immediately.

Mayonnaise with hard-boiled egg and without oil

Preparation time: 15 minutes
Ingredients (serves 4): 3 eggs, 3 tablespoons Greek yogurt, 1 tablespoon mustard, 1 tablespoon wine vinegar, salt, pepper.
Utensils: Blender, saucepan or saucepan.
Step by step: Cook the eggs in boiling water for 10 minutes, cool completely and remove the shell. If you prefer, immerse them in very cold water to accelerate cooling. Place the hard-boiled eggs in the bowl of a blender along with the mustard, Greek yogurt, vinegar, salt and pepper. Blend everything until a creamy and homogeneous mixture is obtained. Add chopped chives if you want to give it a fresh and aromatic touch.

How about you?

Do you usually prepare homemade mayonnaise at home or do you prefer supermarket mayonnaise? Do you have a foolproof recipe or are you one of those who improvise with what you have on hand? Maybe you like it with a touch of lemon, or maybe you like the classic vinegar and thick texture.

Tell us how you make it, if you use whole eggs or just the yolk, and if you have any tricks to keep it intact or to make it last longer. We'd love to read about it in the comments.

You may also be interested in:

Is it safe to eat eggs? Find out how to avoid the risks associated with its consumption.Is it safe to eat eggs? Find out how to avoid the risks associated with its consumption.

Eggs are a staple in our daily diet. It is economical, versatile and highly nutritious. However, its consumption and handling require certain care, especially with regard to food safety and the risk of bacterial infections, such as salmonellosis. Below, we share with you the essential keys to enjoy the benefits of eggs safely.

Are you storing your eggs correctly? Find the right place!Are you storing your eggs correctly? Find the right place!

The question of the ideal place to store eggs is one that permeates the kitchen in many homes. After all, where do these little treasures of nature stay freshest and longest? The fridge or the pantry? This seemingly simple discussion involves scientific and cultural aspects that deserve to be explored.

Around the world with 7 egg recipes!Around the world with 7 egg recipes!

Can you imagine going around the world without leaving your kitchen? With an ingredient as versatile as the egg, it's possible! Get ready for an incredible gastronomic journey, where each recipe is a new stop on this delicious trip. From classic dishes to more modern creations, we'll explore the flavors of different cultures, all with an ingredient we always have on hand: the Egg!

Patricia GonzálezPatricia González
Passionate about cooking and good food, my life revolves around carefully chosen words and wooden spoons. Responsible, yet forgetful. I am a journalist and writer with years of experience, and I found my ideal corner in France, where I work as a writer for Petitchef. I love bœuf bourguignon, but I miss my mother's salmorejo. Here, I combine my love for writing and delicious flavors to share recipes and kitchen stories that I hope will inspire you. I like my tortilla with onions and slightly undercooked :)