How to spot a bad restaurant: 7 warning signs to be aware of
Wednesday 7 May 2025 09:05 - Vincent Sabourdy
Going to a restaurant should always be a pleasure: we go there to relax, to be served, to eat well, to enjoy a moment together, with family or friends. But sometimes, we find ourselves faced with a disappointing experience, or even a complete failure. And while certain signs are unmistakable, you still need to know how to spot them. Here are seven clear indicators, validated by food critics and tested (sometimes to our detriment), that should alert you even before the first bite.
1. An empty restaurant at peak times
Friday evening, 8pm. You walk into a restaurant and... no one. Not a single customer, or just two occupied tables, while all the other establishments in the neighborhood are full. This is often the very first sign that something is amiss. Of course, there's a fine line to be drawn: a restaurant may be new, poorly located, or a victim of unforeseen circumstances. But if this ghostly atmosphere is repeated, especially at key times, there's a good chance that people will avoid it on purpose. And if the locals don't go there, why risk it?
2. Unpleasant or aggressive service
A good welcome can save an average meal. Conversely, unpleasant service can ruin a successful meal. If, on arrival, someone looks at you sideways or speaks to you curtly, this is often a bad sign. And if there's a problem - a wrong dish, botched cooking, an oversight on the bill - the staff's attitude says a lot about the establishment. A waiter who accuses you, shrugs his shoulders or refuses to acknowledge a mistake shows that here, the customer is not the priority. Worse still, it may reveal internal tensions or poor management.
3. Questionable hygiene
Cleanliness is non-negotiable. And it's not just a question of comfort: it's a strong signal of seriousness and respect for the customer. Sticky floors, dirty toilets, poorly cleaned tables... these are all visible signs that should immediately arouse your vigilance. Because if what you see is dirty, imagine what you don't see in the kitchen. Also check the hygiene rating if it's displayed, or take a look at online customer reviews - if they all point in the same direction, you'd better run.
4. Ill-treated, poorly trained or understaffed staff
This point is more subtle, but just as revealing. Servers who are stressed, overworked, poorly organized or clearly unhappy often indicate a management problem. It's not their fault - on the contrary. If a restaurant doesn't train its staff, doesn't listen to them or doesn't respect them, you can feel it everywhere: on the plates, in the service, in the atmosphere. A good restaurant is also a well-treated team. And it shows.
5. A menu that is too long or inconsistent
An 8-page menu of pizzas, sushi, burgers, fondues and pad thai? Run away. When a restaurant claims to do everything, it often doesn't do anything very well. A menu that's too broad usually means frozen products, sloppy recipes and a blurred identity. On the other hand, a short, coherent, seasonal and frequently updated menu is a good indicator of fresh, mastered cuisine.
6. A fake, too Instagrammable atmosphere
A wall of pink neon lights, artificial flowers everywhere, golden armchairs... if everything seems thought out solely for Instagram photos, it's because the culinary experience takes a back seat. Of course, a pretty decor is a plus. But when image takes precedence over taste, you end up with a movie set and a tasteless plate. And the atmosphere can quickly turn into a noisy, uncomfortable gimmick.
7. A massive presence of guest influencers
When every post on the web is labeled #ad or "free meal", the sincerity of reviews should be taken carefully. This doesn't mean that the restaurant is necessarily bad, but if it only exists because of advertising, ask yourself some questions. What's more, these high-profile places often attract crowds that aren't always there to eat, which can spoil the experience for you, the simple diner.
Petitchef's advice
The good news? There are plenty of honest, friendly and tasty restaurants out there. To avoid unpleasant surprises, rely on detailed reviews, observe the atmosphere as you enter, and above all, trust your instincts. And if in doubt... why not cook for yourself? HERE you'll find thousands of simple, tried-and-tested recipes!
What about you? Have you ever had a bad experience in a restaurant? Share your anecdotes or tips on how to spot the good ones!
What about you? Have you ever had a bad experience in a restaurant? Share your anecdotes or tips on how to spot the good ones!
Read also
Rate your favorite restaurants on Tiktok, the feature will soon be available!TikTok is much more than a simple application where you can scroll for hours. It's a veritable showcase for promoting new concepts or recommending places you've loved, thanks to its unpredictable algorithm.
There's always room in your stomach for dessert, and science knows why.Imagine a Sunday afternoon with the family. The table is laden with traditional dishes: a steaming paella, fresh salads and crusty bread. After repeated servings and a toast with wine, you feel you can't take it anymore. You are full, satisfied, perhaps even a little sleepy. But then, someone mentions the chocolate cake waiting in the kitchen. Suddenly, your senses are awakened, and that...
Vincent SabourdyCo-founder and publishing director of Petitchef, I am above all passionate about cooking and the internet.
I make the best crêpes on the street.
I love accessible recipes, practical advice, and culinary news.
My goal: to offer the best possible culinary website to make cooking a pleasant and shared experience.
I make the best crêpes on the street.
I love accessible recipes, practical advice, and culinary news.
My goal: to offer the best possible culinary website to make cooking a pleasant and shared experience.
Comments