Sardines in oil or in water? Find out when each is the best choice

Friday 25 September 2026 15:30 - Mirella Mendonça
Sardines in oil or in water? Find out when each is the best choice
Sardines in oil or in water? At first glance, many people answer without thinking: in water, because it seems lighter. But the best choice isn’t that simple. Whether you’re eating them plain, using them as a filling for a pie, making a pâté, or preparing a hot dish, the oil-packed version can offer more flavor and texture.

The answer depends on three things: the purpose of the meal, the recipe you choose, and what you do with the liquid from the can. Below, find out how to make the right choice every time and how to turn canned sardines into practical, economical, and flavorful dishes.

1. The short answer: it depends on the recipe

Sardines packed in water aren’t automatically better. They’re usually a good choice when you want to limit fat intake, achieve a more neutral flavor, or use sardines in salads and cold dishes.

Sardines in oil also have their advantages. They tend to be more tender, more flavorful, and easier to use in pâtés, fillings, pies, and hot dishes. Instead of picking one as the clear winner, think about the final result you want on your plate.

2. When choosing sardines in water

Choose sardines in water when you want a lighter dish, seasoned to taste. They pair well with lemon, herbs, tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, plain yogurt, black pepper, and a drizzle of olive oil added at the end.

This option is great for anyone looking to put together a cold dish, a protein-packed salad, or a fresher meal. The key is to drain them well and season them generously, since sardines packed in water can have a milder flavor.

3. When choosing sardines in oil

Sardines in oil work best when a recipe calls for immediate flavor and a softer texture. They’re great for fillings, creamy appetizers, quick pasta dishes, pies, and baked goods.

The secret is not to use all the oil right away. Taste it first. In some recipes, a portion of the oil helps sauté onions, garlic, or tomatoes. In others, it’s best to drain it off to keep the dish from becoming too heavy.

Quick and easy sardine rillettesRecipe Quick and easy sardine rillettes

To accompany your aperitif or make an easy no-cook starter, try our sardine rillettes! This quick recipe requires you to mix just 4 ingredients together. Spread on toast or serve with vegetable sticks—here’s a great way to use your cans of sardines...



Sardine saladRecipe Sardine salad

This sardine salad is not only super quick to make, but can also be prepared with ingredients that everyone has at home. It is a perfect appetizer for a snack with friends or any other type of celebration, as it can be served on crispy toast. An...

4. The mistake that changes everything: using the liquid from the can without thinking

The liquid from the can should be treated as an ingredient, not as a requirement. If you’re using sardines in oil, use it only when it makes sense for the recipe. In pâtés and stir-fries, it can be helpful. In salads or dishes that are already creamy, it can make them too heavy.

If using sardines in water, draining them is also usually important to prevent the dish from becoming watery. Then, season with lemon, olive oil, herbs, and spices. The difference between a bland sardine dish and a delicious recipe often lies in this detail.

5. For pâtés and appetizers, the oil-based version usually stands out

For appetizers and hors d’oeuvres, sardines in oil may be a better choice because they help create a creamy texture and a more well-rounded flavor. Even so, it’s best to drain off the excess oil and balance the dish with fresh ingredients.

Lemon, fresh cheese, yogurt, herbs, red onion, pickles, or chili peppers help cut through the fat and make the dish more refined. That’s why sardine pâtés and rolls work so well for entertaining guests or whipping up a quick appetizer.

Zucchini rolls with sardinesRecipe Zucchini rolls with sardines

Here's another recipe to prove that zucchini has more than one trick up its sleeve! Perfect for an appetizer, this no-cook dish is super easy to make and, above all, quick ;-) It's so easy, in fact, that you should invite the kids to help make...

6. For hot dishes, consider the final texture

In oven-baked or stovetop recipes, sardines in oil can make the dish more succulent. Sardines in water, on the other hand, may work better when the dish already includes richer ingredients, such as cheese, eggs, pasta, or a creamy sauce.

If the recipe is baked, mix the sardines with moist ingredients to prevent them from drying out. If it’s a stovetop dish, add the sardines toward the end to keep them in one-piece chunks and prevent them from falling apart too much.

Spaghetti with sardines: an easy, quick, and flavorful recipeRecipe Spaghetti with sardines: an easy, quick, and flavorful recipe

Learn how to make spaghetti with sardines , a simple, quick, economical, and very flavorful recipe that is ready in just a few minutes. Made with canned sardines, cherry tomatoes , garlic, and the oil from the can, this main course uses...



Easy, fluffy creamy sardine blender pieRecipe Easy, fluffy creamy sardine blender pie

This easy, fluffy creamy pie with sardines , made in a blender , is one of those practical recipes that can save any meal. The light batter comes together quickly in the blender, and the flavorful filling is made with well-seasoned sardines. The...



How to make sardine-stuffed zucchini?Recipe How to make sardine-stuffed zucchini?

Easy and quick to make, this sardine-stuffed zucchini recipe is a must if you're looking for a low-calorie, very healthy meal rich in vitamin C and omega-3. It serves 4 and takes just 30 minutes to prepare. Like the suggestion? Then follow our...

Easy and budget-friendly sardine moquecaRecipe Easy and budget-friendly sardine moqueca

One of Brazil’s most traditional dishes, made easy and affordable. Got a can of sardines handy? Open it, because we’re going to use it to make a quick, healthy recipe for everyday meals: the much-loved moqueca with coconut milk and vegetables. Follow...

7. How to make any canned sardines taste better

Drain, taste, and season in layers. Start with a touch of acidity, such as lemon or mild vinegar. Then add herbs, tomatoes, onions, garlic, black pepper, or a drizzle of olive oil. If it’s too salty, pair it with potatoes, rice, vegetables, or bread. If it’s bland, use mustard, parsley, cilantro, or a little tomato sauce.

Practical summary: choose sardines in water when you want a light, controlled flavor; choose sardines in oil when you want flavor and texture. The best option is the one that pairs well with the recipe.
Mirella MendonçaMirella Mendonça
I am the editorial manager at Petitchef (Portugal and Brazil) and a huge enthusiast of travel and world cuisine, always in search of new flavors and experiences. However, as much as I love exploring the delights of different cultures, my mom's cooking will always be my favorite — with that unique flavor that only she can create.

Comments

Rate this article: